Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Is UVA a gentlemen's program?
#11
(02-20-2018, 04:41 PM)Guest Wrote:
(02-20-2018, 04:11 PM)Guest Wrote:
(02-20-2018, 02:52 PM)Guest Wrote:
(02-19-2018, 11:37 PM)Guest Wrote: And from the fact that residents there sexually assault others. So you know, there are valid reasons for the bad rep.

Hmm.  Until recently, it has only been men in that program..

But not interviewees

Maybe a confound is that female applicants don't rank this program highly because it isn't conducive to family life/relationships the same way a program like Pitt isn't.

Sexist much? Welcome to 2018 where not all women want (or can have) a family life or kids. It's because the chief and other senior residents have been known to sexually harass and assault female interviewees and rotators while drunk. And there's more than one report of this happening throughout the years. UVA is KNOWN for this kind of shit and it needs to stop.
Reply
#12
Even if women don't want want a family in my experience every woman I have talked to going into neurosurgery or any other demanding field builds an option in so that they COULD have a family if they wanted. Enough white knight bull
Reply
#13
Multiple known sexual assaults!?!?! If this were true and "common knowle4dge", how could they have a program?!? If you have evidence of this, shouldn't YOU come forward?!
Reply
#14
(02-19-2018, 09:44 PM)maybe Wrote: My friend did a second look there and apparently everyone is happy, does good research, and charlotesville is a great city?

Why the bad rep???

To address the OPs question:

I personally know several attendings who trained under John Jane Sr. as residents, several who have completed competitive spine fellowships under Shaffrey, and one resident who is heading there post-residency for fellowship. UVA has a long history of training academic leaders in neurosurgery and are quite proud of that tradition - and it shows in their demeanor, and in the expectations they have of their trainees.

IMO: UVA does not appear to be a "gentleman's program" from an in-hospital lifestyle perspective, because the clinical demands and expectations are high. During my interview this round, I found the program to be full of actual gentlemen/women (in the traditional sense) and learned that the out-of-hospital lifestyle can be quite grand considering the cost of living in Charlottesville. Coupled with a year in New Zealand, I can understand why everyone who trains there is very happy.
Reply
#15
Wow! Someone has an ax to grind. I did a sub I and interviewed at UVA. If any of the allegations above are true, they are extremely well hidden. There was no clues of the allegations above and they would be very difficult to hide for a month in speaking to and interacting with everyone around the program. The residents seem to be held in high regard. They do work hard and publish a lot. Charlottesville is a college town and may not be for everyone. They gave good camaraderie. UVA has three women in their training program now and looked like they finished a woman a couple of years ago according to the pictures in the conference room. My advice to any other applicant is do due diligence. I kind of hope that some applicants read this message board and ranked UVA lower so that I have a better chance to match there!
Reply
#16
One of the women in the UVA program has a kid and she seems normal and happy to be at UVA. She has no qualms about the program and says Charlottesville is a great place for family.
Reply
#17
Pretty sure that like 50% of the residents are married or have kids. Most of them seem to like Charlottesville, but I have heard some of the west coast or NY people in their program don't as much. Not sure about reality, but reputation wise it seems they know all the right people and their chiefs the last few years seem to have all gotten good jobs or fellowships.
Reply
#18
This type of thing happens every single year around rank time - people start trash talking programs in the hopes that other people rank them lower, with the idea that they have a better chance of matching there. Its unfortunate really, but comes with the territory of a forum designed around posting anonymously.

To those of you that just put in your rank lists - the wait begins, good luck with the match!
Reply
#19
(02-22-2018, 08:12 AM)Guest Wrote: This type of thing happens every single year around rank time - people start trash talking programs in the hopes that other people rank them lower, with the idea that they have a better chance of matching there. Its unfortunate really, but comes with the territory of a forum designed around posting anonymously.

To those of you that just put in your rank lists - the wait begins, good luck with the match!

Nice cover, UVA guy. Haters gon hate
Reply
#20
I interviewed at UVA. I can't speak about some of the stuff in this string but I had concerns about attrition and asked every level resident about this during interviews and meals. As far as I could tell, they have not lost any residents in the seven years the current residents have been there. This might have been an issue before. I think UVA is a top program for academic practice. There is not much there to teach you about private practice.
Reply


[-]
Quick Reply
Message
Type your reply to this message here.

Image Verification
Please enter the text contained within the image into the text box below it. This process is used to prevent automated spam bots.
Image Verification
(case insensitive)

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)