Let's hear it!
Personally:
1. Barrow
2. Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Pitt, UCSF, UVA
3. Baylor, Brigham, Columbia, Cornell, Duke, Emory, Florida, Indiana, Jefferson, Johns Hopkins, NYU, OHSU, MGH, Miami, Michigan, Northwestern, Penn, Stanford, UT Southwestern, Utah, UC Irvine, UCLA, U Wash, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Utah, USC, Washington St. Louis, Wisconsin,
4. Carolinas, Dartmouth, Georgetown, Iowa, Mayo Jacksonville, Maryland, Minnesota, Mount Sinai, Penn State, Rochester, Rush, UNC, VCU, Yale, NIH,
5. Albany, Buffalo, George Washington, Henry Ford, Hofstra, entucky, LSU, MUSC, Rutgers, Tenessee, UCSD, UI Chicago, USF, Vermont, UT Houston, Wake Forest
6. Alabama, Allegheny, Beth Israel, Brown, Einstein, Geisinger, Mississippi, Houston Methodist, New Mexico, Nebraska, NYMC Westchester, Oklahoma, St. Louis, SUNY Upstate, UI Peoria, Wayne State, West Virignia, Temple, U Chicago,
6. Tulane, Medical College of Wisconsin, LSU Shreveport, Scott and White, UT Galveston, Louisville, Arizona, Missouri, Cincinnati, Medical College of Georgia, Puerto Rico
Reviewer #1: No discussion of methodology whatsoever. Poor discussion. Recommendation: Reject
(11-19-2018, 01:55 AM)Guest Wrote: Reviewer #1: No discussion of methodology whatsoever. Poor discussion. Recommendation: Reject
lol
Posts: 48
Threads: 4
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation:
2
11-19-2018, 09:53 AM
(11-19-2018, 01:37 AM)sumguy Wrote: Let's hear it!
Personally:
1. Barrow
2. Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Pitt, UCSF, UVA
3. Baylor, Brigham, Columbia, Cornell, Duke, Emory, Florida, Indiana, Jefferson, Johns Hopkins, NYU, OHSU, MGH, Miami, Michigan, Northwestern, Penn, Stanford, UT Southwestern, Utah, UC Irvine, UCLA, U Wash, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Utah, USC, Washington St. Louis, Wisconsin,
4. Carolinas, Dartmouth, Georgetown, Iowa, Mayo Jacksonville, Maryland, Minnesota, Mount Sinai, Penn State, Rochester, Rush, UNC, VCU, Yale, NIH,
5. Albany, Buffalo, George Washington, Henry Ford, Hofstra, entucky, LSU, MUSC, Rutgers, Tenessee, UCSD, UI Chicago, USF, Vermont, UT Houston, Wake Forest
6. Alabama, Allegheny, Beth Israel, Brown, Einstein, Geisinger, Mississippi, Houston Methodist, New Mexico, Nebraska, NYMC Westchester, Oklahoma, St. Louis, SUNY Upstate, UI Peoria, Wayne State, West Virignia, Temple, U Chicago,
6. Tulane, Medical College of Wisconsin, LSU Shreveport, Scott and White, UT Galveston, Louisville, Arizona, Missouri, Cincinnati, Medical College of Georgia, Puerto Rico
 
Reviewer #2: Obvious lack of attention to detail. Numbered list incorrectly formatted with use of same number on more than one occasion. No methodology reported, hard to discern criteria used to make this tiered system (operative volume, autonomy, research?). Would recommend further analytical work with attention to detail and reporting of methodology before acceptance into a peer-reviewed forum. Reject until further work is completed.
Reviewer #3:
Accept, no changes. We need these types of ground breaking, provocative statements.
Tiering like that isn't helpful to future applicants that care about program style/fit. Is this framework below helpful? If so, feel free to fill it out based on your experiences in your sub-internships. Consider that one person's #1 may be a program you wouldn't even rank based on widely differing priorities/location preference/etc. Obviously programs go in multiple groups here.
-- general tiering
High volume/low research:
Balanced:
Low volume/high research:
Record of strong academic placement regardless of volume/research:
-- misc
International experience:
Affordable city (ie can you buy a decent house w resident money):
Residents/attendings are very good friends with each other:
-- concerns
Concern for very low case load:
Concern for high attrition rate:
(11-19-2018, 11:06 AM)Guest Wrote: Tiering like that isn't helpful to future applicants that care about program style/fit. Is this framework below helpful? If so, feel free to fill it out based on your experiences in your sub-internships. Consider that one person's #1 may be a program you wouldn't even rank based on widely differing priorities/location preference/etc. Obviously programs go in multiple groups here.
-- general tiering
High volume/high research:
High volume/low research:
Balanced:
Low volume/high research:
Low volume/low research:
Record of strong academic placement regardless of volume/research:
-- misc
International experience:
Affordable city (ie can you buy a decent house w resident money):
Residents/attendings are very good friends with each other:
-- concerns
Concern for very low case load:
Concern for high attrition rate:
Copyright © UWorld, Please do not save, print, cut, copy or paste anything while a test is active.
Amended.
(11-19-2018, 01:37 AM)sumguy Wrote: Let's hear it!
Personally:
1. Barrow
2. Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Pitt, UCSF, UVA
3. Baylor, Brigham, Columbia, Cornell, Duke, Emory, Florida, Indiana, Jefferson, Johns Hopkins, NYU, OHSU, MGH, Miami, Michigan, Northwestern, Penn, Stanford, UT Southwestern, Utah, UC Irvine, UCLA, U Wash, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Utah, USC, Washington St. Louis, Wisconsin,
4. Carolinas, Dartmouth, Georgetown, Iowa, Mayo Jacksonville, Maryland, Minnesota, Mount Sinai, Penn State, Rochester, Rush, UNC, VCU, Yale, NIH,
5. Albany, Buffalo, George Washington, Henry Ford, Hofstra, entucky, LSU, MUSC, Rutgers, Tenessee, UCSD, UI Chicago, USF, Vermont, UT Houston, Wake Forest
6. Alabama, Allegheny, Beth Israel, Brown, Einstein, Geisinger, Mississippi, Houston Methodist, New Mexico, Nebraska, NYMC Westchester, Oklahoma, St. Louis, SUNY Upstate, UI Peoria, Wayne State, West Virignia, Temple, U Chicago,
6. Tulane, Medical College of Wisconsin, LSU Shreveport, Scott and White, UT Galveston, Louisville, Arizona, Missouri, Cincinnati, Medical College of Georgia, Puerto Rico
Bloated tier 3
(11-19-2018, 01:37 AM)sumguy Wrote: Let's hear it!
Personally:
1. Barrow
2. Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Pitt, UCSF, UVA
3. Baylor, Brigham, Columbia, Cornell, Duke, Emory, Florida, Indiana, Jefferson, Johns Hopkins, NYU, OHSU, MGH, Miami, Michigan, Northwestern, Penn, Stanford, UT Southwestern, Utah, UC Irvine, UCLA, U Wash, Vanderbilt, Tufts, Utah, USC, Washington St. Louis, Wisconsin,
4. Carolinas, Dartmouth, Georgetown, Iowa, Mayo Jacksonville, Maryland, Minnesota, Mount Sinai, Penn State, Rochester, Rush, UNC, VCU, Yale, NIH,
5. Albany, Buffalo, George Washington, Henry Ford, Hofstra, entucky, LSU, MUSC, Rutgers, Tenessee, UCSD, UI Chicago, USF, Vermont, UT Houston, Wake Forest
6. Alabama, Allegheny, Beth Israel, Brown, Einstein, Geisinger, Mississippi, Houston Methodist, New Mexico, Nebraska, NYMC Westchester, Oklahoma, St. Louis, SUNY Upstate, UI Peoria, Wayne State, West Virignia, Temple, U Chicago,
6. Tulane, Medical College of Wisconsin, LSU Shreveport, Scott and White, UT Galveston, Louisville, Arizona, Missouri, Cincinnati, Medical College of Georgia, Puerto Rico
You’re dumb. So many idiotic choices.
|
